Extensive discussion about my article "Progenitor of Wars and Tyrannies: the Falsehood of Pan-Arabism" in the Political Forum

One of my most popular articles ever proved to be the devastating rejection and denunciation of Pan-Arabism that I published under the title "Progenitor of Wars and Tyrannies: the Falsehood of Pan-Arabism" in several portals notably American Chronicle, Buzzle and AfroArticles in the mid-2000s. It was thence extensively and widely mentioned, discussed, quoted and republished in portals, sites, and blogs. Indicatively, I herewith include the following links: https://www.aramnahrin.org/English/Muhammad_Shamsaddin_Progenitor-of-Wars-And-Tyrannies_29-6-2004.htm 

http://aramean-dem.org/English/History/8.htm (paragraph ending with note 5) https://phoenicia.org/panarab.html http://www.aramnaharaim.org/English/opinion_analyse.htm https://goodmaniac.blogspot.com/2012/06/libyans-and-people-of-maghreb-are.html https://www.maroc.nl/forums/het-nieuws-van-de-dag/217670-telquel-zijn-geen-arabieren-onze-geschiedennis-vervalst-4.html 

https://arabracismislamofascism.wordpress.com/category/pan-arabism/ https://www.geocities.ws/panarabism/ https://mergueze.info/arabism-racism/ http://www.allempires.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=2905&PN=3 

Even here (!):https://context.reverso.net/translation/english-dutch/pan-arabism 

Slightly edited, the integral standard version of the article can be found here: https://www.academia.edu/23219268/Prof_Muhammad_Shamsaddin_Megalommatis_Progenitor_of_Wars_and_Tyrannies_the_Falsehood_of_Pan_Arabism 

However, in its original form, this article was published in the Political Forum on 23rd June 2004, generating a fascinating polarization and many conflicting comments. That's why I am herewith reproducing the entire discussion, which can still be found here: https://www.politicsforum.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=25086 

I must however add that my very first publication on the topic goes back to 1988, and it took the form of a 11000-word entry (in Greek) in the Great General Encyclopedia Hydria (published by Etaireia Ellinikon Ekdoseon / Greek Publications Co) – Μεγάλη Γενική Εγκυκλοπαίδεια Υδρία (Εταιρεία Ελληνικών Εκδόσεων). The entry title was 'Φυλές και Λαοί της Μέσης Ανατολής' (Peoples and ethnic groups in the Middle East). In my Curriculum, it is mentioned as no 37 in the first unit of my Entries to Encyclopedias, here: 

https://megalommatiscomments.wordpress.com/about-prof-muhammad-shamsaddin-megalommatis-entries-of-encyclopedias/  

Download the discussion in PDF here: 

https://www.academia.edu/52038684/Extensive_discussion_about_my_article_Progenitor_of_Wars_and_Tyrannies_the_Falsehood_of_Pan_Arabism_in_the_Political_Forum